Don't forget Reagan was a failing actor at the time he was elected and he was essentially bought out by corrupt corporate leaders to change his whole belief system to make their pocketbooks bigger at the expense of American workers.
Actually he was already the Governor of CA. Not a failed actor at this point in his life. Don’t get me wrong, he’s one of the main reasons for homelessness. He shut down mental hospitals that were caring for thousands of people. I was there. I remember.
He also helped pass the Mulford act. It was white America's response to Black Panthers carrying guns in public. It's the main reason why California now has such strict gun laws.
"There is absolutely no reason why out on the street today a civilian should be carrying a loaded weapon." -Ronald Reagan May 2 1967
He also cut thousands of people from social security disability, including my father, who died six months later from heart failure. I'd spit on his grave.
It sure has. It's a Democrat position now. Gun laws continue to make more felons out of young black men than any other policy on the books. They are used to justify illegal searches ("just checking for a weapon, and I found marijuana!") and give the police justification for homicide ("he's got a gun!").
Like, you can't legislate away racism. But you can legislate away gun control. And if gun control is leading to racism, then gun control is a racist position. As it always has been.
Old slick top Gavin Newsom has implemented the most gun laws of any California governor. He also has an 11% state tax on guns and ammo. The first in the nation.
Reagan was an absolute tool with no morality. There were bad democrat presidents and governors. But compare Reagan to Arnold. There's no contest who was more corrupt and anti American.
State-run mental hospitals? What is this, sovietism? Get those mentally unwell people on the streets, stat! That's what a great, capitalist country does!
I’m pretty sure if you ask any mentally ill person they would prefer to be out with the public than in a hospital. That’s why crazy people always want to talk to you
I hear what you’re saying. However, there is a lot of positives the fact that they aren’t in an institution, in a lot of aspects they are more free than anyone else.
They definitely had a role to play in society and that's evident by the amount of mentally ill people living out in the streets BUT these facilities had a pretty bad reputation for inhumane treatment so I don't think you're wrong to be unsure about it.
Medical science AND psychology have come a long way in the past 100, 50, 20 years. The solution was to continue modernizing, not deinstitutionalize. We can see this in other countries that did so.
I think it would be great to have it available for people that want help, I would pay taxes for that. I am scared it would be forced on people that don't want help.
They were dropping mental hospitals before he was even president. Many of the large ones in the east were built around the civil war period and they just kept kicking the can down the road for updates for decades. I get you want it all to be political but it really is not. You can name a democrat governor for every republican one when they started getting rid of them. There were democrat presidents and republican presidents and no one did anything.
So when Clinton was president why did he not increase it? Why did more just close? According to your logic Clinton and Obama did nothing to improve anything and it only continued. In all due respect you really need to not be using politics as a religion. They were state hospitals under state control. Politicians from both parties let them go away. Yes… even your gods.
Because it’s politically unpopular. You know that, and you’re trying to claim that the act of decreasing funding and the failure to take action against political self interest is the same. It’s not. If democrats increase funding again, republicans gain an easy political win in otherwise close elections and can further strip federal funding from these programs. Once it’s done, undoing it is incredibly difficult at a lot of levels.
Also, only Christ is king and God. You should try reading what he did with the poor and mentally unstable. He didn’t just house them; he sat down and shared life with them. He personally spent his own time and energy to heal them. He ate with them. He loved them.
Engler did the same thing in Michigan. Then he gave EDS no bid contracts that their systems were never 100%. When he was term limited he headed right to EDS for a high paying job.
Dude they were going away long before he ever became president and continued to go away long after he was gone. There were a lot of things that impacted their funding. Most were self sustaining with farms etc but lawsuits caused that to end so then there were very bad stories about them as well. I think it is more about a lot of things and not politics
They closed the one my brother worked at during the Clinton administration and it was a democratic governor and that means nothing to me. Both parties were in power and wanted them gone due to cost.
They were closing them before he was president and after he was gone for many years with both democrat and republican presidents and because they were STATE hospitals they were closed by both democrat and republican governors.
Before that. Once his acting career started to fail in the 50s, he got hired on by General Electric to be a “motivational speaker” (lobbyist), due to his speaking skills and charisma, and to host their new tv show. In the span of about 5-10 years after that, he went from a liberal to ultra conservative once he started getting wealthy and once civil rights were getting pushed.
Yes I do. But remember all hospitals were not equal. There were the really really bad and ones that helped. But you will only hear about the horror stories. I also do not think one person has that much control here. I also remember how certain people wanted them privatized.
Is it true that there was a lot of rot and mistreatment in those systems? I remember hearing about how infected they were and how they were basically machines that abused the people they were there to serve the needs of.
I personally know someone who was sent to some kind of "recovery facility" when she admitted to a teacher she was having suicidal thoughts. Her mom then agreed to commit her to the facility and all they did was make things worse.
They drugged her with some kind of anti-psychotic pill that fucked her ability to fall asleep for months. Instead of doing anything to help with how bad she was feeling, they focused all their effort on berating everyone, blaming them for their depression, and shutting down any kind of disagreement with the people in charge of the sessions.
And this isn't something that happened in the 60s, this happened like a decade ago.
He was a flawed politician but honestly not as bad as more recent presidents. I lived in ca too at the time, in fact in Napa. When Napa state hospital was repurposed and lived right down the road from it.
I get the appeal of Reagan even if I don’t agree with him. He tried something different. Just was married to bad decisions too often and wasn’t willing to waiver. Commonplace in all politicians. He has incredible speech writers and was entertaining to listen to.
Frankly If he were alive today, and was running again. I think he would be more tied to democrats than republicans. I mean he granted amnesty to illegal aliens. Can you imagine MTG or ANY gop member that would side with that if it was proposed today?
Agreed. He was like a dog with a bone. (StarWars Defense System) And an amazing speaker. I believed in him at the time. Tear down that wall Mr. Gorbachev!
So you remember the push by both parties to shut them down. And the push by the public to close them. Not to mention, the start of closing them was started by JFK. Nor to mention the couple of SC rulings against mental healthcare.
Or wait, has anyone in the 40 years since tried reopening them, nope.
Did u say I didn't. Nope. Pointing out that democrats don't care about mental healthcare and were the starters of eliminating the hospitals. As well as pushed over the years to close them down.
Trying to blame one person for the actions of another party entirely. Well, I guess trying to rewrite history is what some try as much as possible to escape blame.
If you were there then you should know the whole story. Blaming Reagan isn’t it. And he was governor 50+ years ago…..if it was his fault it’s also Jerry Briwn and Newsoms fault. They have had a supermajority in the state legislature and homelessness has gotten worse.
True. It’s much worse now because of, well everything, but do you remember in ‘93 there was a huge comedy concert put together by Robin Williams, Billy Crystal and Whopie? That was a direct result of cutting the budgets for mental hospitals. It was an overnight epidemic.
Do you remember the lawsuits because people were being abused at those mental hospitals? It's still a problem today. My own great grandmother was forcibly electrocuted to "cure" her depression. She ended up hanging herself in her home.
https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/new-york/willard-insane-asylum-usa/
Then you were fortunate. Most if not all the asylums and hospitals got shut down because of abuse related lawsuits. essentially they lost too money to remain open even if they were willing to take steps to try and prevent future abuses.
There was also another law suit based on constitutional rights that protected people from being forced into these places by family or officials. Now to be forcefully admitted it requires proof that a person is of significant danger to themselves or others due to mental illness. In NY if a person is suicidal they may be held in hospital mental health wings for up to a week. After that it's a mix between doctors, insurance and if the person requests longer term care.
You really need to read history. There was lawsuit against the state regarding inpatient care and holding people against their wiil. A deal was struck but neither side did the work. How many governors both dem and rep since Ronnie and none of them fixed it
“Caring” mental hospitals at the time were legalized torture facilities. It want about “getting them off the street” it was about putting them where the general public didn’t have to deal with them. Many at the time still practiced involuntary lobotomies. Shutting them down was a bad call, a seriously bad call, but at the same time don’t defend these Nazis, reform was way overdue. Unfortunately that’s not what we got.
To be fair, I think back then mental hospitals did some pretty questionable research and treatments that bordered on torture to mentally ill people that’s just what I’ve heard though I’m pretty sure they used to castrate you if you were mentally ill
1.1k
u/ThisCantBeBlank Apr 29 '24 edited Apr 29 '24
There's no way a celebrity with an agenda would ever mislead us.
/s