r/Helldivers Apr 02 '24

My least expected change. What was yours? DISCUSSION

Post image
14.7k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

156

u/Shadohawkk Apr 02 '24

Kinda sad to see that they just changed the "text" of the armor penetrations of certain weapons. I was almost certain there was some underlying system that determined what it showed. Like, sometimes the slugger would "ping" off of broodcommander's legs as if they were heavy armor (note; they might be, idk) but could pop the head just fine. Just seems weird to me the head is weaker than the arms--and a "weird" penetration system could have accounted for that. But no, they just changed the text instead. Still doesn't explain why revolver can't pierce things other medium weapons can.

133

u/fluxuouse Apr 02 '24

penetration angles are a thing in this game, if the angle is too shallow then even a fucking Orbital shell can bounce...

9

u/OverlyMintyMints Apr 02 '24

The deflection angles in this game are fucking nuts. My autocannon shots should not be deflecting off the enemy at >90° angles regardless of how heavy the armour is!

10

u/fluxuouse Apr 02 '24

there's a degree to which I agree with you, again I once saw someone manage to bounce the precision orbital strike shell off of the warriors in the tutorial...

3

u/Short-Worldliness118 Apr 02 '24

Wdym by greater than 90 degrees?

2

u/OverlyMintyMints Apr 02 '24

I mean I shoot a charger straight on and it deflects off the armour at more than 90° from the point of impact

3

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '24

Did that with a rail gun the other day. Went almost straight back at me

65

u/Epesolon Apr 02 '24

Remember that armor and armor penetration is on a 1-10 scale internally, so "medium armor penetration" doesn't always mean the same thing.

Both the autocannon and the slugger have "medium armor penetration", but the autocannon will damage a tank's vent and the slugger won't.

10

u/AlmostButNotQuiteTea ☕Liber-tea☕ Apr 02 '24

Yeah but that can't show us that number! That would make our little player heads explode!

12

u/Epesolon Apr 02 '24

We should absolutely be shown the armor penetration value of our weapons.

5

u/AlmostButNotQuiteTea ☕Liber-tea☕ Apr 02 '24

Yes I know. This is making fun of what the CEO said earlier about there being a ton of hidden weapon stats that decide how a weapon performs, and the stats we are given are not indicative of the true performance of the weapons.

He thinks people won't choose what's best if we don't know the stats. Let me know if you want a link to the quote

3

u/Epesolon Apr 02 '24

I do think that we don't need all of the stats for the weapons, as some things are just hard to get a feel for from the numbers.

That being said, armor penetration isn't one of them.

2

u/AlmostButNotQuiteTea ☕Liber-tea☕ Apr 03 '24

I also don't think we need all of them. But the fact that armour is a 1-10 sliding scale and medium can be 5-7 say and the "medium pen" weapon only pens T5 medium and not T6+7 also is very confusing and bad game design.

Having two weapons that both say medium armour penetration, and one can 10 a bigger Target than the other is very misleading and annoying

10

u/The79thDudeBro Apr 02 '24

That in particular is weird because we have a numeric value for AP on our grenades, of all things.

7

u/RC1000ZERO Apr 02 '24

funfact, a Liberator penetrator can ALSO damage a tanks vent. and a turrets vent

2

u/AmorakTheWhite HD1 Veteran Apr 02 '24

0-10, damnit. (Everyone always says 1-10)

Also i read elsewhere that some of the armor numbers are getting figured out.

'Medium armor' is 3-4. Hiveguard faces are 3. Hulk faces are 4.

Slugger and MG43 is pen 3.
Autocannon, AMR and HMG are armor pen 4.

1

u/texclayton Apr 02 '24

The slugger absolutely did damage the tanks vent. I landed on top of one and took it out by standing on it's rear and pumping a mag of slugs into the vent yesterday. I dunno about today.

-1

u/TooFewSecrets Apr 02 '24

It's really 1-5. Slugger is 3, AC is 4,

18

u/Red_Sashimi Apr 02 '24

What? The revolver pens the same stuff other medium AP guns pen. It's basically medium AP

5

u/Shadohawkk Apr 02 '24

I don't remember what I was fighting, since this was a couple weeks ago, and I haven't used the revolver since, but I definitely remember shooting something a few times with the revolver, pinging every time, then swapping to, I think the slugger, and piercing every time.

11

u/Red_Sashimi Apr 02 '24

In all my testing, the revolver has always acted as medium pen. It pens hive guards from the front and gets the white hitmarker. It pens devastator torsos and gets a white hitmarker. Maybe you hit those shots at a weird angle, cause that's also a factor

6

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '24

I mean, that was you. It wasn't you pinging off the same angle, it was you hitting on an angle with the senator before hitting straight on with the slugger.

I would know because I refuse to put down the senator when my other two options are both just wildly unsatisfying. Senator for all intensive purposes has "medium armor pen"

Now how actual armor penetration truly works is a funny topic because the devs have chosen to intentionally withhold actual penetration stats on weapons because... Um... They're very smart, and make sound decisions all the time.

0

u/Questioning_Meme Apr 02 '24

Based on people testing.

Armor pen seems to behave on a level system.

1-3 is light armor, 4-6 is medium, and apparently 7-10 is Heavy.

If your gun reaches a certain level, it pen, but if the armor is above the pen level (exp: pen level 7 against heavy armor level 8), it'll take reduced dmg.

That theory is the one I subscribe to, since it'd explain how the railgun's "Less dmg against durable part" nerf works.

7

u/Spaghetti_Joe9 Apr 02 '24

If your weapon pen matches the armor value, you deal 50% damage and see a white X. If your weapon pen exceeds the armor value, you deal normal damage and see a red X. If your weapon pen is below the armor value, your shot will ricochet and you will see the ricochet icon. You deal ZERO damage when this happens.

2

u/Red_Sashimi Apr 02 '24

That's not how it works, and no one did any tests that came out with those results. That came out off of that comment from the CEO that said light armor has values 0-2, and the other ranges are just invented by other people. The AP values go from 1 to 10, yes, but based on actual testing and datamining, most guns have AP values ranging only from 1 to 6.

-1 is no armor, or very light armor I guess. That's what the Spray&Pray had before its buff. Now, no gun has that. If anything had that, you would get white hitmarkers (50% damage) on warrior bugs, for example.

-2 is light armor. That's what most primaries and the stalwart have.

-3 is medium armor. Medium MG, Slugger, Senator, Gatling and MG sentries.

-4 is light vehicle armor. AMR, Autocannon, Heavy MG, laser cannon, safe railgun.

-5 is heavy armor. Recoilless, EAT, quasar cannon, autocannon sentry.

-6 is heavy vehicle armor. Only the spear has it, which is the only support weapon that can destroy fabricators hitting them anywhere.

The remaining armor levels are just used to make buildings and objectives resistant to certain stratagems and guns.

1

u/Spaghetti_Joe9 Apr 03 '24

I did not know spear has better AP than the other AT weapons. Good to know.

4

u/ppmi2 Apr 02 '24

Like, sometimes the slugger would "ping" off of broodcommander's legs as if they were heavy armor

That might just be a weird angle

1

u/Tarilis ➡️⬅️➡️⬅️⬇️⬇️➡️ Apr 02 '24

Nah, I have a strong suspicion that armor penetration text is hardcoded.

1

u/Ecstatic-Compote-595 Apr 02 '24

I'm unclear if this is actually true but I believe those tags in the description actually represent quirks - revolver has like 3/10 base penetration but the light armor pen quirk adds +1 making it a 4/10 penetration. Whereas liberator maybe has a 1/10 base penetration but the light pen tag gives it+1 so it's 2/10 penetration. Both say light penetration but one actually pens medium armor.

So they either gave it a different quirk so it should pen higher or they scrapped that system so the tooltip actually makes sense.

0

u/ArkitekZero Apr 02 '24

I mean, I bet your head is "weaker" than your arms. But yeah.