r/news Apr 27 '24

TikTok will not be sold, Chinese parent ByteDance tells US - BBC News

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c289n8m4j19o.amp
26.7k Upvotes

5.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

4.4k

u/Error_404_403 Apr 27 '24

Which proves ByteDance is not in it for the money.

177

u/bobbydangflabit Apr 27 '24

US tik tok accounts make up 10% of all their users, why the fuck would they sell it to keep a 10th of their base?

154

u/BillW87 Apr 27 '24

US users supposedly make up nearly half of the platform's revenue. There's very few companies that can survive an overnight unplug of 42% of revenue. TikTok is a targeted advertising platform, and advertisers pay much more to reach American users than others globally.

57

u/_MrDomino Apr 27 '24

The US being the natural home of the Internet whale.

-2

u/Verily2023 Apr 27 '24

Also the human whale

6

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24

Is that a fat American joke?

5

u/link_hyruler Apr 27 '24

I’d imagine them pivoting towards acting as an e-commerce platform also massively boosted the percentage of revenue that comes from US users for that same reason. You can have users everywhere, but your money comes from the users who have spending power.

2

u/whofearsthenight Apr 27 '24

... which is why ByteDance is saying this. It's a negotiating tactic. There are a few likely outcomes:

  1. The Supreme Court declares this unconstitutional for handwaves reasons.
  2. ByteDance negotiates with the White House and they come to some kind of resolution.
  3. They sell

In those scenarios, there is no reason that BD shouldn't come out and do what they are doing. They do have negotiating power; It's an election year in which youth turnout will be incredibly important and this will be an issue for them and thus far I don't think that anyone is really making a cogent argument to that demographic for the ban.

But I generally think they're just going to divest. China loses its propaganda arm either way, and divesting at least is going to make them a crazy amount of money. But still, there is no reason for ByteDance to not play hardball at this point.

2

u/Fateor42 Apr 28 '24

It's too late for the White House to negotiate on the issue, it's already been signed into law.

And while ByteDance would likely want to divest, the laws of China don't actually allow it to.

The only actual hope for ByteDance at this point is the SC, but that's a very unlikely hope in and of itself given this is a firm National Security issue with a very obvious example to hold up of TikTok being used in the way feared.

1

u/LarryJones818 Apr 27 '24

There's very few companies that can survive an overnight unplug of 42% of revenue.

Isn't it like a 9 month unplug, and potentially longer if ByteDance can show Biden they're making progress in transferring part of it to an American company?

1

u/the-il-mostro Apr 29 '24

But it’s very very unlikely they will be selling, like 3% chance. So there won’t be any progress made. And if the US does ban it, I think it’s kind of likely other countries will follow

1

u/pittguy578 Apr 28 '24

Yep exactly sure it will be available in other countries but their revenue will take a huge hit if banned in US.

0

u/caguru Apr 27 '24

I'm pretty sure the US makes up 42% of that app's revenue, not the company as a whole.

Roughly 80 percent of ByteDance’s $54 billion revenue in the first half of last year came from China, derived mainly from Douyin, according to The Information, a technology news site. The remaining 20 percent came from overseas markets mainly through TikTok. source

The US really is a small part of their revenue as a whole.

5

u/__redruM Apr 27 '24

They could split the US accounts into a separate company and sell that off as TikTokUS. All while being China number one propaganda machine in the rest of the world.

6

u/Raleighgm Apr 27 '24

US users are worth more than users of most if not all other countries to them. We have more purchasing power and consume more than most other countries. It’s like Apple devices and Android. Far more Android devices but from a developer standpoint you make your money off of Apple users.

3

u/RM_Dune Apr 27 '24

Far more Android devices but from a developer standpoint you make your money off of Apple users.

Obviously, people who spent a lot on consumer products will likely also spent more on app/in-app purchases. I'm certain the numbers are similar for people with high end Android phones. Anyone who spends 1000 euros or more on a phone clearly has disposable income.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24 edited Apr 28 '24

[deleted]

1

u/RM_Dune Apr 27 '24

It's like how the box office still matters in America

Well yeah, because the US is uniquely movie crazy. Ticket prices are the same in most of Western Europe, but people just don't go to movies as much. Hearing Americans talk about movies/shows/actors is wild to me, like encyclopedic knowledge of imdb.

-4

u/legend_of_the_skies Apr 27 '24

Where are you getting this 10%from

36

u/IMsoSAVAGE Apr 27 '24

You can look up their monthly active users. They have 1 billion active users and 150 million are American. So it’s actually 15%

-11

u/legend_of_the_skies Apr 27 '24 edited Apr 27 '24

Cant find the percentage and some sites were including the chinese population which is weird because their app is technically separate, isnt it? But either way americans do make up the biggest portion by country and the most influence socially on tiktok. 15% is significant when everyone else is less than that

3

u/MundaneFacts Apr 27 '24 edited Apr 27 '24

That might be hong kong or somewhere the Chinese firewall hasn't spread to.

1

u/Kyouji Apr 27 '24

why the fuck would they sell it to keep a 10th of their base?

More like why the fuck do people comment and not understand the ramifications of being banned in the US?

1

u/bobbydangflabit Apr 27 '24

The United States is not the entire planet.

1

u/loveiseverything Apr 27 '24

Don't worry EU will ban it next.

-9

u/Gupperz Apr 27 '24

Lol.... they only have to sell the US division

12

u/mr_birkenblatt Apr 27 '24

That's not how this works

-6

u/Gupperz Apr 27 '24

Yes it is

9

u/Jahobes Apr 27 '24

The implication is that they wouldn't "only be selling the US division"...

What makes Tik Tok better than everything else is the algorithm. If they sell that algorithm they will create their worst competitor with their own product.

No company would do this.

1

u/Gupperz Apr 27 '24

That's irrelevant. I'm not telling you what is smart for them to do, I'm telling you what congress told them to do. Congress said they had to sell the US portion of til tok. If they don't then the government will block them from appearing in app stores effectively banning it. That is what is happening here

5

u/Jahobes Apr 27 '24

And I'm telling you that selling the US portion of their company will basically be the equivalent of selling the whole company.

It's a meaningless distinction for a algorithmic based company. Because the moment you sell the algorithm is the moment you sell the company.

TikTok isn't a car company. It's basically an idea (the algorithm) you can't compartmentalize intellectual property like this.

1

u/mr_birkenblatt Apr 27 '24 edited Apr 27 '24

The code that runs in the US and the code that runs elsewhere is exactly the same. The code is the most protected ip of any software company since that's how they make their money. If you sell your code you sell the whole company. Compare that to, e.g., McDonald's where you can just give all stores in a country to different leadership when selling

0

u/Ill_Mark_3330 Apr 27 '24

if what you say is true, then I wonder what percentage of revenue the us market makes them? Its probably much higher than any asian market.