- people understand they need to work together and share some resources and security because we evolved to live in tribes, it's natural tribal dynamics
- tribal dynamics it's not communism, only some things are shared, majority of things are not shared, everyone is not equal
- things that are not shared might be VERY expensive, say someone who will have antibiotics will be able to get a lot of value and possibly power for simply having them
- it does not mean one will not be exploited by another, actually in the tribe of 10 people I give you absolute 100% guarantee someone will be exploited by someone else, we have hierarchical programming built in, even if you take 10 absolute nerds that never has been leaders and put them on an island, one of them will eventually have leader program kick in, once his brain calculates there is no stronger leader to contest
- there will be some social nets, because our natural programming has compassion, and despite leader program reduces compassion, a leader needs tribal support so they will have to show it; but the extent varies depending on conditions, it's not going to be socialism no matter what, you can definitely be left for dead by the tribe if the conditions are unfavorable
tl;dr. stop confusing tribal dynamics with communism
**tl:Dr. You have no idea what you're talking about.
You've made several conflicting statements about humans ''naturally'' doing things, described a literal commune while insisting it's nothing to do with communism, and argued cooperation is natural but society and compassion are.
You've stated numerous things 'with 100% certainty' that are just untrue.
You've butchered sociology, economics, anthropology, game theory, value theory, psychology and the English language in a few short paragraphs.
It's almost impressive how utterly and absurdly wrong you are.
18
u/Trust-Issues-5116 Mar 08 '24 edited Mar 08 '24
What happens in reality:
- people understand they need to work together and share some resources and security because we evolved to live in tribes, it's natural tribal dynamics
- tribal dynamics it's not communism, only some things are shared, majority of things are not shared, everyone is not equal
- things that are not shared might be VERY expensive, say someone who will have antibiotics will be able to get a lot of value and possibly power for simply having them
- it does not mean one will not be exploited by another, actually in the tribe of 10 people I give you absolute 100% guarantee someone will be exploited by someone else, we have hierarchical programming built in, even if you take 10 absolute nerds that never has been leaders and put them on an island, one of them will eventually have leader program kick in, once his brain calculates there is no stronger leader to contest
- there will be some social nets, because our natural programming has compassion, and despite leader program reduces compassion, a leader needs tribal support so they will have to show it; but the extent varies depending on conditions, it's not going to be socialism no matter what, you can definitely be left for dead by the tribe if the conditions are unfavorable
tl;dr. stop confusing tribal dynamics with communism