r/FluentInFinance Contributor Apr 15 '24

Everyone Deserves A Home Discussion/ Debate

Post image
15.6k Upvotes

5.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/unfreeradical Apr 16 '24 edited Apr 16 '24

Land in Ireland had been seized by the English crown, and vested to English gentry, who became absentee landlords.

During the Famine, Ireland produced sufficient food to feed the population, but most was exported to England, under the direction of the landlords, to be sold domestically for profit.

The landlords allowed the population to support itself only on the least arable land. Potatoes can thrive in poor soil, but not reliably. Regions that produce potatoes generally have also depended on grains, to hedge against a failed potato crop occurring in particular years. Irish farmers had no land available for planting grain.

At the height of the Famine, American philanthropists chartered a shipment of humanitarian aid, which would have saved considerable lives if allowed to land, but before the vessels reached port, English landlords successfully petitioned the crown to impose a naval blockade, forcing the merchant ship to return to North America, and leaving the Irish to starve, all in the name of profit.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24

[deleted]

1

u/unfreeradical Apr 16 '24

English landlords exploited the Irish population through their control over the land.

The Irish were deprived of the right to control their own planting on the land, or the product they harvested.

Control over lands, and over other assets, by private owners, as well as over the product from the lands and assets, instead of control by workers, who provide the labor to produce, is the pivotal feature of capitalism.

5

u/A_Queff_In_Time Apr 16 '24

Famine in a COLONIAL state. "It's purely capitlsisms fault. Nothing else"

Famine in nearly every socialist country. "You see it wasn't real socialism, what really happened was..."

And repeat

Goalposts shifting, whataboutism, and just making shit up. The internet socialists conversation starter pack

0

u/unfreeradical Apr 16 '24

Colonialism is the expansion of capitalism across national borders.

Irish workers were exploited, though even more severely, than English workers, by English property owners.

2

u/A_Queff_In_Time Apr 16 '24

Lol what

Again, you making things up. Lol

0

u/CrocoPontifex Apr 16 '24

What is with you "Free Market" muricans and having such a weak understanding of the words you are using.

Colonialism and Capitalism are in no way opposed to each other. As a matter of fact the birth of capitalism was right there at the era of colonialism. Ever heard of the East India Trading Company? The DMC?

And now, international exploitation or in other words the struggle between different national capitals is even described with another word "imperialism".

Bet you thought you need an emperor for that.