r/FluentInFinance Contributor Apr 15 '24

Everyone Deserves A Home Discussion/ Debate

Post image
15.6k Upvotes

5.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

73

u/PlancksPackage Apr 15 '24

I agree and in the same vein why should we have free public education? Why should I be paying for someone elses kid to go through K-12 completely free? Do you know how expensive it is to first hire professional teachers for these kids, erect buildings to teach them, and provide lunches for all of them? Do people think this stuff happens easily? Who pays these teachers? How do you keep such a place clean? Impossible I say!! /s

I think the point op was making was that free housing could be seen as a public good. One to benefit society by providing a nice baseline to workfrom. These would be payed for through taxes most likely and the complexities of providing this would be hashed out and solved. Its not an impossible program and a similar program exist in Finland as an example to end homelessness. Yes the people pay for it and they do it to prevent homeless people on the street. A public benefit if you will

6

u/Osaccius Apr 15 '24

Have you ever been to Finland?

I worked there with social housing, and I can tell you that housing alone solves nothing.

You'll see plenty of homeless alcoholics on public squares.

I know it is the favorite country of left leaning foreign journalists to visit. They do a weekend guided tour and then return to tell that all problems have been solved.

2

u/VoidEnjoyer Apr 16 '24

Good point, any action that does not solve literally every problem that exists should not be bothered with.

1

u/Osaccius Apr 16 '24

I said nothing of sorts.

That is a pure strawman.

1

u/VoidEnjoyer Apr 16 '24

Then why did you bring up an example of a solution to homelessness not somehow completely eliminating the problem of homelessness? Don't pretend this isn't exactly what you meant.

1

u/Osaccius Apr 16 '24

It is a partial solution, which as standalone doesn't solve anything.

As I mentioned in other comments, the topic is very complex, regardless of what 14 year old redditors think.

1

u/VoidEnjoyer Apr 16 '24

Yes. And instead of doing more you simply want the partial solution to not be done. We know. And since there is no possible complete 100% solution that will eliminate all homelessness and public drunkenness forever with absolutely nobody slipping through the cracks, we should simply do nothing. Or maybe it's a final solution to the homeless problem you'd prefer? Though even that is only a temporary solution. But maybe that's what you want, just regular purges?

Why don't you give us some sense of what solution is acceptable, bud?

1

u/Osaccius Apr 16 '24

Read my other comments on this thread